Funds For Learning filed reply comments on November 12 in the second round of the FCC’s review of E-rate, WC Docket 26-133. We asked the Commission to streamline the program the record shows is working instead of narrowing it, and to design any new oversight so its burden falls on the parties that don’t follow the rules and spares applicants. We measured each proposal by whether it helps schools and libraries, makes the program simpler to use, and is best for applicants. 

Nearly half of students are below the FCC’s bandwidth benchmark 

The FCC’s own 2026 Section 706 Report found that 52 percent of students had access to at least 1 Mbps per student in 2025. That leaves 48 percent below the short-term benchmark the Commission uses. We told the Commission that this finding answers its question about whether E-rate has fulfilled its mission. 

Our reply comments also cited our count as of October 14, when 2,479 of the 2,514 filings that took a position on the program’s future urged the Commission to preserve it. Our review of the reply round puts the total across both rounds at 2,702 of 2,740 as of November 15. The share is 98.6 percent in both counts, and both include form letters and repeat filings. Commenters describe connectivity as a recurring cost that would move to local budgets if the discount ended. 

A rural-only program would leave out ability to pay 

The FCC asked whether support should be limited to rural or single-provider areas, or phased out where NSLP participation is lowest. We opposed all three. The FCC’s own notice says affordability depends on both the cost of service and the ability to pay, and a geographic limit addresses only cost. A high-poverty district that buys service in a competitive market still faces a bill it can’t meet from local funds. 

The discount matrix already accounts for cost and need together, including through the rural differential. We asked the Commission to keep it as it stands and to keep accepting Community Eligibility Provision data. 

Special construction should also stay eligible under the existing competitive bidding and cost-effectiveness rules. We asked the Commission to make network security eligible as well. In our 2026 survey, 97.5 percent of respondents said network security and network management should qualify for support. 

Three proposals would fall hardest on the smallest applicants 

To be fair to the FCC, several of its proposals would make the application process simpler and fairer, and we supported them in our opening comments. Three others would fall hardest on the smallest schools and libraries. 

  • Requiring every consortium member to file its own Form 479 in EPC would push that work onto members that joined a consortium to avoid it. Consortium leads should keep collecting letters of agency and member certifications. 
  • Eliminating managed internal broadband services (MIBS) would remove the service most used by applicants with no IT staff. MIBS should remain eligible. 
  • Holding or rejecting an applicant’s pending forms when a third party’s certification is late would put the consequence on the applicant instead of the party that failed to act. 

We also supported removing the Emergency Connectivity Fund rules, as long as pending invoicing, appeals, and audits continue and the order says when document retention ends. 

Screen-time conditions wouldn’t reach devices or classrooms 

E-rate doesn’t fund the devices, software, and classroom practices that determine screen time, so a funding condition on the connection can’t reach them. States, school boards, and parents already make those decisions. Head Start and pre-kindergarten eligibility should continue to follow state law. 

Where we stand on consultant oversight 

The FCC also proposes to define, register, and certify E-rate consultants. As a firm that helps applicants with their filings, we have a stake in those rules. 

We continue to support the proposed definition of consultant, including its breadth. Other filers asked for a narrower definition or for carve-outs, and we don’t discount those concerns. Under the registration we proposed, the applicant decides who has access to its EPC account, and every party it authorizes declares its role, who pays it, and any tie to a provider of E-rate-eligible services. That works under any definition the Commission adopts. The registrant should be the employer, identified by its Employer Identification Number, so no individual’s home address, date of birth, or Social Security number goes into a federal database. 

Consistent with our opening comments, we opposed the proposed ban on percentage-based fees and any requirement that fees be reported to a federal administrator or listed publicly. What an engagement costs is settled in contracts that applicants’ own governing boards approve and pay with local funds. An applicant that uses no consultant shouldn’t have to certify to that every year, because its EPC account already shows whether it has authorized anyone. 

What happens next 

The comment cycle closed on November 12, and no rules have changed. Nothing the FCC proposed takes effect until it adopts an order. Our review of the reply round covers what other filers said. You can also read our full reply comments and our opening comments, including the data and citations. If you have questions about what these proposals could mean for your applications, contact your E-rate Guide or reach out to us. 

About the Author: Eric Jester is an E-rate Guide at Funds For Learning. He joined 16 years ago, drawn by a long-held belief in the importance of education and a desire to put his analytical skills to work in communities that benefit from them. Eric leads and develops Guides on one of the Guide Teams, building the processes, alignment, and capacity that let Funds For Learning support clients well. Outside of work, you’ll find him with his wife and daughter (living the cheer dad life), traveling when he can, and playing guitar when time allows.